Academic Freedom as the Foundation of Excellent Research, Teaching, and
Technology Transfer at RPTU
Senate Paper
Background
Academic freedom is essential for universities to fulfill their societal mission: to gain knowledge, to test certainties, and to empower students to think independently. The Constitution protects it, and society places a high degree of trust in academia. This is precisely why it is worth actively defending and further developing it. For it is currently under pressure: from the outside, for example, through political attacks by right-wing populist actors and societal debates, or through academia’s stance on geopolitical and societal conflicts; from the inside, for example, through the shift from declining base funding to increasing project-based funding.
This places a special responsibility on universities: On the one hand, they must ensure openness to a broad spectrum of scholarship and a diversity of perspectives; on the other hand, they must take a clear stand when scholarship comes under pressure.
With this position paper, the RPTU makes it clear that it not only advocates for academic freedom but also seeks to make a constructive contribution to democratic society. The paper is intended as a catalyst for discussion and a signal to strengthen academic freedom in research, teaching, and knowledge transfer at RPTU. It consists of three parts:
(1) a contextualization of academic freedom within the framework of research, teaching, and knowledge transfer at RPTU, (2) an appendix with specific questions and answers, and (3) a collection of literature and recommendations for further discussion.
Democratic and Constitutional Prerequisites for Academic Freedom
The RPTU is a center for academic research and teaching as well as a forum for social debate. It creates spaces for exchange where different perspectives, experiences, and insights can come together. Based on academic standards, some of these perspectives are examined, further developed, and negotiated. As a public institution, it helps to draw on impulses from society, critically monitor social developments, convey knowledge to society, and promote open discourse on issues of the past, present, and future.
The RPTU regards academic freedom as an indispensable foundation of its work. Academic freedom depends on a reliable democratic framework grounded in the rule of law. Research, teaching, and knowledge transfer flourish in a liberal democracy based on the rule of law, which is underpinned by fundamental rights, pluralism, and protection against arbitrary influence. Academic freedom depends on this system and, at the same time, contributes to its critical self-understanding. Conversely, a liberal democracy thrives on an academic community that is independent, critical, and guided solely by scientific findings and arguments.
At RPTU, the organization actively fulfills its responsibility to uphold the freedom of research and teaching and advocates for openness in scholarly discourse. It creates and safeguards spaces where questions can be raised and/or debated impartially, controversially, and independently of political, social, or ideological constraints. At the same time, academia also recognizes tensions, shortcomings, and threats to the democratic order and critically addresses them. Liberal democracy and the rule of law are therefore not only protective frameworks for academia but also subjects of scholarly criticism and democratic self-examination.
The RPTU thus stands for a science that is free because it is anchored in a democratic order secured by the rule of law, and that uses its freedom to accompany this order in a reflective, responsible, and independent manner. It is thus committed to academic freedom as a constitutionally protected fundamental right and an indispensable prerequisite for independent research as well as for the critical examination of social and political developments.
Academic Freedom Between Pluralism and Democratic Limits
Democracy is not limited to majority decisions but is fundamentally characterized by the protection of fundamental and minority rights. These rights are also functional prerequisites for scholarly work at RPTU, as they enable the incorporation of diverse perspectives and protect against pressure to conform. In particular, the fundamental right to academic freedom itself protects the expression of scientific positions held by outsiders and minorities.
The protection of minority rights serves to safeguard the equal participation of individuals and groups in academia and society. It is also an expression of a liberal, constitutional order that, in the spirit of a resilient democracy, opposes efforts to undermine its own foundations. It follows that the protection of minorities does not justify the recognition of arbitrary positions or ideologies as equal contributions to scientific discourse.
Scientific plurality thrives on openness to criticism and reasoning, as well as on a serious, systematic attempt to ascertain the truth. Positions that negate these foundations—particularly those based on inequality, exclusion, or misanthropy—are, in the view of the RPTU, contrary to the democratic and constitutional prerequisites of academic freedom.
Against this backdrop, it must be noted that neither academic freedom nor the protection of minorities gives rise to an unrestricted right to equal treatment in scholarly discourse. However, such statements may, provided the relevant legal requirements are met, fall within the scope of protection afforded by freedom of expression.
For RPTU, this means keeping spaces open for controversial and even contentious debates, while at the same time safeguarding the conditions under which such debates are possible in the first place. It thus bears the responsibility for ensuring academic openness without compromising the normative foundations of academic freedom. Free scholarship depends on these prerequisites, as it can fulfill its function only under conditions of institutionally guaranteed freedom, legal certainty, and social openness.
Academic and Public Discourse
The university is both a place of scholarly research and teaching and a forum for societal debates. However, particularly in exchanges with the public, politicians, and the media, scholarly findings are often drawn into contexts of interpretation and evaluation in which arguments are based on criteria unrelated to scholarship.
At RPTU, a space is maintained for critical engagement in which controversial positions, speech and counter-speech, as well as constructive debate, all have their place. At the same time, it is essential to clearly distinguish between scientific knowledge, its interpretation, and scientifically grounded conclusions on the one hand, and (political) opinions, normative evaluations, and recommendations for action on the other.
Science and Teaching as Part of Social Responsibility
At RPTU, it regards stimulating processes of thought and reflection as its core mission, primarily in teaching, but also in scholarly discourse and in society. According to Section 16 of the Rhineland-Palatinate Higher Education Act (HochSchG RLP), it is also part of universities’ statutory mission to empower students to act responsibly in a free, democratic, and social constitutional state—a task that goes far beyond the mere transmission of knowledge.
At RPTU, this dual mission—knowledge and empowerment—is addressed concretely through teaching: It creates spaces for critical engagement, fosters a culture of scholarly reflection, and enables students and faculty to participate in societal debates. The specific implementation of this mission lies within the responsibility and freedom of its members, as academic freedom applies first and foremost to every person engaged in scholarly work and to the institution itself.
International Cooperation as an Enabler of Excellent Research
Today, excellent research, teaching, and knowledge transfer are embedded in global knowledge structures and depend on diverse forms of international cooperation. At RPTU, the university sees itself as an open and networked institution that actively promotes exchange across national, cultural, and academic boundaries. It expressly welcomes international students, scholars, and partner institutions and regards their perspectives as an indispensable enrichment for processes of knowledge, innovation, and academic culture. Openness to diverse scholarly traditions, experiences, and research questions not only enhances the quality of research but also contributes to fostering a reflective, pluralistic, and responsible understanding of scholarship.
Questions and Practical Applications
As a researcher, do I have to be neutral?
In state educational institutions, public-sector employees covered by collective bargaining agreements, as well as civil servants, are subject to the applicable obligations regarding political neutrality and the impartial performance of their duties. Rather, there are status- and function-dependent obligations to uphold the Constitution. While civil servants are obligated under Section 33(1), sentence 3 of the Civil Service Act (BeamtStG) to commit to the free democratic basic order and to advocate for its preservation, the scope of the corresponding duties of loyalty for employees covered by collective bargaining agreements depends on their specific function and scope of duties (Section 3(1), second sentence, of the TV-L)
It follows from this that researchers may not, in the course of their work, engage in targeted advocacy for or influence against political parties. However, an objective examination of political parties and their positions (e.g., in teaching) is permitted; indeed, advocating for the free democratic University Charter is even required.
This is particularly relevant when extremist or anti-democratic positions are expressed in university courses. While the freedom of science and teaching under Article 5, Paragraph 3 of the Basic Law (GG) requires openness toward controversial and even politically radical positions, it does not oblige faculty members to accept unlawful statements or violations of others’ rights without objection. Rather, an obligation to intervene appropriately and to clarify the constitutional limits of academic and political expression may arise from official duties as well as the rights of the individuals concerned.
The requirement of moderation also extends to the off-duty conduct of civil servants, for example, in public political statements, on social media, or in interviews. Their freedom of political activity and freedom of expression are, in principle, safeguarded. However, they are obligated to observe the necessary moderation and restraint. In this context, particular consideration must be given to their official position and the associated impact on the public. This is relevant, for example, when professors align themselves with a political party (e.g., campaign appearances, pointed political statements related to their official duties).
Specifically, what am I allowed to do—and what am I not allowed to do—as a faculty member? Are there any examples?
As a guideline for conduct—for example, in teaching—the following applies: Generalizations should be avoided, and the distinction between scholarly findings and personal opinions should be clear. You may not engage in campaign advertising while performing your official duties, but you may address facts; situations may also be evaluated from the perspective of the free democratic University Charter. You should avoid appealing to students’ opinions; instead, give them space to articulate their own views. You may also objectively contextualize these opinions within the framework of the free democratic University Charter, such as by addressing issues of discrimination.
You may convey factual information about political parties, such as their positions and political actions, their leadership and elected officials, their connections to other organizations, or decisions by government agencies and court rulings. You may engage critically and reflectively with the goals and positions of political parties, such as by discussing quotes from party platforms or statements by individual politicians. They may also classify positions that are racist or otherwise incompatible with the free and democratic University Charter accordingly and correct false factual claims. They may even express their own views, provided these are clearly identified as such and are not the only position presented.
You may not call on people to vote for or against specific parties. You may also not disparage parties in an unobjective manner, make false factual claims, or call for the disruption of prohibited and/or non-prohibited demonstrations and other events.
But I can always express my opinion. What is the difference between freedom of science and freedom of expression?
Both are enshrined in Article 5 of the Basic Law, but they are distinct fundamental rights with different scopes and underlying principles of protection. Freedom of expression (Article 5(1) of the Basic Law) applies to all people, regardless of profession or status. It protects the expression of opinions, value judgments, and political positions—including those that are pointed, one-sided, or biased. However, it may be restricted by other laws, including the duty of restraint under civil service law (Section 60(2) of the Federal Civil Service Act [BBG]/Section 33(2) of the Civil Service Act [BeamtStG], see above).
Academic freedom (Art. 5, para. 3 of the German Basic Law) protects every person who is engaged in or wishes to engage in academic work. It protects research, teaching, and the freedom to advocate scientific findings—including the communication of science and scholarship. In particular, it protects even uncomfortable, controversial, or pointed scientific theses.
A faculty member who, in a scholarly lecture, advances a radical, socially controversial thesis regarding their own field of research is operating within the core realm of academic freedom, which is protected—even if it appears politically charged—as long as it constitutes a methodologically sound scholarly statement. This must be distinguished from the question of whether and to what extent partisan political statements without a subject-matter basis—such as those made on talk shows or social media (e.g., “You should vote for Party X” or “Government Y is incompetent”), are still covered by the protection of general freedom of expression and to what extent the duty of restraint under civil service law must be observed in this regard (see above).
The distinction is not always clear-cut. For example, a climate researcher may derive recommendations for political action based on her research findings. In each individual case, it must be examined whether the statement is still protected as a scientific opinion under the freedom of science pursuant to Article 5(3) of the Basic Law, or whether it also constitutes an independent expression of political opinion that is additionally protected under Article 5(1) of the Basic Law. This must be distinguished from the question of whether—and to what extent—the person in question is subject to duties of moderation under civil service law. [Further information]
As a civil servant, am I allowed to demonstrate?
Civil servants are generally permitted to participate in demonstrations and express political views, provided they observe their duties of moderation and restraint under civil service law and comply with applicable laws. Whether a specific political statement or a particular behavior is compatible with these obligations requires an assessment of the circumstances of the individual case. In particular, the content, form, and context of the statement, as well as the specific role and professional conduct of the civil servant in question, must be taken into account. Participation in a demonstration directed against the free democratic University Charter may therefore, depending on the circumstances of the individual case, constitute a violation of the civil servant’s duty of loyalty to the constitution. In this regard, the objectives of the event, the specific circumstances of participation, as well as the civil servant’s own conduct and discernible stance are particularly decisive. However, mere participation does not automatically constitute a violation of the duty of loyalty to the Constitution. Rather, a case-by-case assessment is required to determine whether the behavior suggests a lack of willingness to uphold the free democratic basic order.
May I expel students who make racist or anti-Semitic remarks from the course?
Expulsion from the classroom may be considered, in particular, if the behavior significantly disrupts the proper conduct of the class, infringes on the rights of other participants, or if the undisturbed conduct of the class can no longer be guaranteed.
It should be noted that racist or anti-Semitic remarks do not automatically justify expulsion from the class solely on the basis of an assessment of their content. Rather, an assessment of the specific circumstances of the individual case is required. Of particular importance are the content and intensity of the statement, its contextual setting, any repetition, and the impact on the other course participants and the teaching process.
An expulsion from the classroom must be based on a corresponding authority under higher education law or other statutory provisions and must satisfy the requirements of the principle of proportionality. In this regard, particular consideration must be given to the student’s freedom of expression under Article 5(1) of the Basic Law, the academic freedom under Article 5(3) of the Basic Law (if applicable), the freedom of occupation under Article 12 of the Basic Law (if applicable), and the rights of the other participants. If a less severe but equally effective measure is available, it must be applied first.
In the case of significant or ongoing disruptions, however, a temporary exclusion from the current course may be justified.
What else do I need to keep in mind as an academic?
It is important that you continually reflect on your role and act in a manner consistent with that role. The Humboldt University of Berlin’s guidelines on professional ethics elaborate on this: “Given the often-overlooked distinction between academic freedom and freedom of expression, scholars who are active in the public sphere and participate in controversial debates there bear a special responsibility. They must be expected to follow a code of professional ethics that is guided by the fundamental principles and virtues of the scientific pursuit of knowledge while also taking into account the foreseeable consequences of their own actions:
• At public events, scientists should take care to clarify their role as speakers: Are they reporting on their own scientific research, reporting on the research of others, presenting textbook knowledge, or speaking as citizens on topics in which they have no specific subject-matter expertise?
• Transparency is particularly important when presenting theses that are controversial within the field. It contradicts the principle of scientific integrity to present controversial matters as uncontroversial.
• Scholars should exercise great caution when claiming that their academic freedom is being restricted. Academic freedom, of course, does not include the right to speak unchallenged at public events or to be spared even sharp criticism. Nor does it justify a claim to be invited to specific events.” (Source)
Where can I turn if I’m unsure or feel attacked?
It is important to seek a conversation early on, either with the respective deans or the university administration. It also helps to discuss incidents together within teaching teams. For example, some departments have a collegial discussion group on this topic.
In the event of specific attacks, you can contact either the Human Resources Department or Department 3.4 (Legal Affairs), or reach out directly to the university administration at any time. If you need counseling outside of RPTU, you can also contact Scicomm-Support, the national contact point for attacks and unprofessional conflicts in science communication. https://scicomm-support.de/
Further Reading and Recommendations for Action
Guidelines on Professional Ethics for Researchers at Humboldt University of Berlin (2024). https://www.hu-berlin.de/medien-und-kommunikation/aktuelles/details/berufsethischer-leitfaden-fur-wissenschaftler-innen-an-der-humboldt-universitat-veroffentlicht
DFG (2026). Position Paper on Strengthening the Freedom and Resilience of the Sciences. Guidelines and Recommendations. https://www.dfg.de/de/aktuelles/neuigkeiten-themen/info-wissenschaft/2026/ifw-26-45
Gärditz, K.-F. (2026). Intimidation Through the Requirement of Neutrality? Forschung & Lehre. https://www.forschung-und-lehre.de/recht/einschuechtern-mittels-neutralitaetsgebot-7890
Henke, J. & Pasternack, P. (2025). Higher Education in an Uncertain Democracy: Approaches to Strengthening Resilience. Policy Paper, Institute for Higher Education Research at Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg https://www.hof.uni-halle.de/web/dateien/pdf/HenkePasternack_HS-in-der-ungesicherten-Demokratie.pdf
Siggener Impulse (2025). Strengthening Resilience: How Science Communication Can Counter Uncertainty and Threats. https://www.bundesverband-hochschulkommunikation.de/fileadmin/user_upload/projekte/siggener-kreis/Siggener-Impuls-2025.pdf
Guidelines for Good Science Communication (2016, 2025): https://www.bundesverband-hochschulkommunikation.de/fileadmin/user_upload/verband/oeffentliche-dokumente/Leitlinien_ueberarbeitet_-_Stand_06.03.2025.pdf
Wandt, Julia (2026) Should Scientific Institutions Take a Stand? https://www.wissenschaftskommunikation.de/duerfen-wissenschaftseinrichtungen-haltung-zeigen-96199/
Websites
EN:DIRA – Educational Sciences Network: Discourse Intervention Against the Far Right, e.V. https://endira.hypotheses.org/
Scicomm Support: the national contact point for attacks and unwarranted conflicts in science communication. https://scicomm-support.de/